The Adversary

Starred review from October 23, 2023
Crummey (The Innocents) offers a spellbinding novel of cutthroat sibling rivalry in remote late-19th-century Mockbeggar, Newfoundland, where the desolation of the “gaunt, ascetic coastline” is as much an adversary to locals as the story’s primary antagonist, Abe Strapp. A diabolical reprobate, Abe shows up late to his own wedding, an arranged marriage to the 14-year-old daughter of a rival merchant. The ceremony is cut short by an objection from Abe’s older sister, the Widow Caines, who claims Abe raped a young servant named Imogen Purchase. Imogen is four months pregnant, and Abe, a notorious drunk, doesn’t remember if he forced himself on her as charged. As the story unfolds, Crummey teases out the widow’s machinations, showing how she manipulates Abe to get the upper hand on their competing fisheries and mercantile concerns. Abe marries Imogen instead of his intended bride, and as he simmers with anger at his sister, the plot builds toward a violent conclusion. Along with a vivid setting and memorable characters, Crummey impresses with his dexterous use of language to convey the time period. (Though the widow’s late husband was “even-handed and generous,” most locals had a different take: “He’d lend his arse and shit through his ribs, people said dismissively, as if he was a guileless cake.”) This gripping page-turner is Crummey’s masterpiece.